Susan L. Furgeson

Susan L. Furgeson


Susan is an attorney and member of the subrogation arbitration team for McNeelyLaw LLP. She has been focused on subrogation law since 2012 and spends nearly all of her time handling subrogation claims in the inter-company arbitration process. Susan files arbitration on a variety of claims ranging from small fender-benders to large, complicated fire and water losses.

Her focus on inter-company arbitration has provided her with the opportunity to learn the unique aspects of the arbitration rules and procedures and to develop an understanding of the evidentiary materials most likely to lead to favorable outcomes. Prior to working in subrogation, Susan handled insurance defense litigation and insurance coverage matters as well as commercial litigation and general business matters.


  • George Washington University Law School, Washington D.C.
  • DePauw University, Greencastle, Indiana (magna cum laude)

Bar Admissions

  • 1995 Indiana

Courts of Practice

  • U.S. District Court – Northern District of Indiana
  • U.S. District Court – Southern District of Indiana


  • Indiana State Bar Association
  • National Association of Subrogation Professionals
  • Shelby County Bar Association

Civil & Community Involvement

  • Major Health Partners Foundation’s Planned Giving Committee
  • Major Health Partners’ Patient & Family Advisory Council

Areas of Practice

  1. Subrogation

meet our team. McNeelyLaw LLP
is a full-service law firm with
attorneys practicing in 21 areas of law.